Subscribe

Giovanni Smith spent over a decade in construction, rising from estimator to project leader overseeing multimillion-dollar ventures and teams of 50+. But he and his business partner had been living a different life for years—as top hosts on Toro, the car rental marketplace. They knew the platform's weaknesses intimately: hosts had no control over pricing, customer experience suffered, and when problems arose, owners were left to fend for themselves. In November 2020, during the pandemic, Giovanni and his partner decided to build something better. Subscribe launched with a mission to replace the chaotic marketplace model with a managed, regulated ecosystem.

Subscribe's core insight was simple: instead of a free-for-all marketplace where prices and service quality varied wildly, they'd create a platform where Subscribe maintained control. Car owners would supply assets, Subscribe would regulate pricing through its hubs, manage maintenance, and orchestrate the entire customer experience. "We regulate the prices, we regulate the experiences," Giovanni explained. Unlike traditional marketplaces, Subscribe didn't force owners to compete on price. This was fundamentally different from Toro's model, where car owners undercut each other constantly.

By April 2021 (six months in), they had bootstrapped the operation entirely. No outside capital—just Giovanni, his partner, and a lean team of 2-3 full-timers supported by about 12 part-time contributors helping with development, marketing, and operations.

Their initial inventory came from their own Toro operations. They "flipped" their existing cars from Toro over to Subscribe, giving them a head start of roughly 30 vehicles across 10 owners—all based in Toronto. The marketplace began to attract renters who preferred the simplicity: no long-term contracts, no day-rental awkwardness, just weekly or monthly access to nice cars at a fixed rate. Average daily rates ranged from $120-$150, with most renters committing to a minimum of 3-4 days (ideally pushing toward weekly bookings for better pricing). By April, they'd logged 20 renters.

The math was straightforward: 20 renters × ~$500 average transaction (3-4 days at $150/day) × 20% take rate = ~$2,000 in April revenue. Subscribe's commission came from two sources: a 20-30% cut of the rental transaction and variable insurance premiums based on renter age and experience (approximately 25% of total revenue in April). But scaling the supply side proved harder than attracting renters. Giovanni saw massive opportunity: OEMs and car dealerships were themselves moving into subscription models, and he wanted to partner with them to get more inventory.

His pitch to car owners was compelling: if you list a $60k-$80k car on Subscribe, expect $2,000-$3,000 in monthly revenue, or roughly $24,000-$36,000 per year at ~255 rental days per year. But Giovanni faced a critical question from Nathan Latka: would he actually *guarantee* those numbers? His answer revealed both ambition and honesty. He couldn't guarantee 255 days outright—but he had a solution: diversify each car's revenue beyond rentals. Movies, weddings, events, private bookings. That way, if Subscribe couldn't hit the rental target, the car owner would still make money, reducing their risk of pulling the car off the platform.

With $2,000 in April revenue ($24,000 ARR), Subscribe was still tiny but showed real traction in a tough category: the two-sided marketplace. Giovanni was bootstrapped, sleep-deprived (3-4 hours per night), and intensely focused on solving the supply constraint. His vision extended far beyond insurance or commissions—he saw Subscribe as an asset management and optimization platform that would eventually serve events, media production, and corporate fleets. The hard part wasn't proving demand; it was convincing car owners that Subscribe could reliably keep their assets booked.