← Back to browse

Lily's Sweets

by Cynthia Ticevia How I Built This
Growthproduct led growth
Pricingone-time
The Spark

Cynthia Tice was nearly 60 years old when she decided to launch what would become a multi-million dollar brand. Rather than pursuing the typical entrepreneurial trajectory in her youth, Tice identified a personal pain point: her love of chocolate conflicted with her desire to eat healthily. She set out to create something that didn't exist in the market at the time—an indulgent, sugar-free chocolate treat sweetened with stevia instead of traditional sugar.

Building the First Version

The path to Lily's Sweets wasn't smooth. Tice experimented with recipes, but early attempts were disastrous. However, she persisted through the failures, refining her formula until she had a product she believed in. Her timing proved crucial: she correctly predicted that a growing segment of shoppers would willingly pay a premium for healthier treat options.

Finding the First Customers

Lily's Sweets achieved a remarkable feat for a startup confectionery brand—a national launch in Whole Foods, the premium natural foods retailer. This was accomplished with a lean team of just four employees, suggesting either exceptional execution or a co-packing arrangement that allowed the small team to focus on sales and operations rather than production.

Where They Are Now

Ten years after its launch, Lily's Sweets had grown into a significant player in the healthy snacking category. The brand's success caught the attention of Hershey's, the global confectionery giant, which acquired Lily's Sweets for $425 million. This acquisition validated Tice's original insight about consumer demand for better-for-you chocolate products and represented a remarkable return on what was likely a modest initial investment.

Similar Companies

Calendly

$2.5M/mo

Tope Awotona founded Calendly after three failed startups taught him the importance of solving real problems rather than chasing money. He spent six months validating the scheduling tool idea by studying competitors' products and user forums, then went all-in by emptying his bank account and hiring engineers in Ukraine. Calendly achieved product-market fit through a freemium model that optimized for invitee experience, growing to 4 million users and $30M ARR largely through organic viral growth and word-of-mouth.

Copy

$2.5M/mo

Copy is a SaaS product that achieved $30M ARR and 1,000+ G2 reviews without building an outbound sales team. The company leveraged product-led growth and word-of-mouth strategies to drive adoption and credibility on review platforms like G2.

Nomad List / RemoteOK

$250k/mo

Pieter Levels is a solopreneur who built Nomad List and RemoteOK, generating nearly $3M in annual revenue with zero employees while maintaining a nomadic lifestyle. The episode features him discussing his approach to building sustainable solo businesses, the philosophies behind indie hacking, and how to think bigger as a solopreneur.

Pieter Levels' AI Startups Portfolio

$250k/mo

Pieter Levels is a prolific indie hacker and entrepreneur running multiple AI startups that collectively generate $250,000 in monthly recurring revenue. Despite claiming "Indie Hacking is dead," Pieter exemplifies how the practice has evolved in the age of AI tools and platforms, discussing topics from dependency risks to preparing businesses for potential exits while maintaining a strong presence on social media.

Sheets & Giggles

$200k/mo

Sheets & Giggles is a pun-based, eco-friendly bedding brand founded by Colin McIntosh that launched in May 2018 on Indiegogo. The company makes lyocell bed sheets from eucalyptus trees and achieved nearly $500K in revenue in their first 6 months with over 6,000 orders, now generating $200K monthly revenue.